Artificial Turf and Crumb Rubber

Printer Friendly, PDF & Email

Modern artificial turf is used indoors and outdoors in a wide variety of settings, including multipurpose recreational and professional sports fields, playgrounds, residential areas, and public streetscapes (base of trees, sidewalks), and public parks. This product is thought to play an important role in urban environments by increasing play space, reducing injuries, allowing play under adverse weather, and at the same time decreasing water use compared to natural turf. However, concerns have been raised regarding cancer and other health risks from exposure to the chemical constituents of artificial turf blades and crumb rubber infill, which include heavy metals, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs).

While there may be public concern over artificial turf, the evidence to support decision-making on the use of these materials has critical gaps. The following resources have been assembled to help explain the types of evidence available, its strengths and limitations, and the data gaps yet to be filled. Links to several previous comprehensive reviews of artificial turf and its health effects are included here, as well important upcoming research that aims to fill critical data gaps.

NCCEH Resources

  • Artificial turf: Contributions and limits of toxicology in decision making (Eykelbosh 2019)
    This article, and the accompanying presentation delivered at the 2019 Public Health Association of BC Conference, briefly reviews recent human health risk assessments on artificial turf and discusses the expected contributions of several major upcoming projects. The paper also discusses risk communication and management approaches, as well as the need to expand the knowledge base around artificial turf and move toward a more community-based decision-making process.​

  • Artificial turf: Contributions and limits of health research in decision making (Eykelbosh 2019)
    This presentation, delivered at the 2019 Public Health Association of BC Conference, briefly reviews the contributions of human health risk assessments to decision-making on artificial turf, and discusses risk communication and management approaches to address health concerns.

  • This annotated bibliography provides a quick reference to the most recent human health risk assessments that have estimated cancer risks and non-cancer hazards for crumb rubber.
  • Assessing the evidence for decision-making on artificial turf: a new hierarchy of evidence (2016)
    This guidance document provides a brief overview of the different types of evidence that have been used to assess the safety of artificial turf. This document is not intended to provide a detailed review of the results, but rather to discuss the strengths and limitations of certain approaches and how these different studies contribute to the overall knowledge base.

Selected External Resources

Upcoming Research

In recognition of the fundamental data gaps in our understanding of the health effects of exposure to artificial turf (see above), two large studies have been initiated in the US.

  • Federal Research Action Plan on Recycled Tire Crumb Used on Playing Fields and Playgrounds
    This initiative, carried out by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), and the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), has four objectives:
    1. Produce an up-to-date systematic review of the literature on artificial turf, its chemical constituents, human exposure, and human health effects;
    2. Characterize the chemical composition of tire crumb from a variety of sources, with and without weathering. Tire crumb samples will also be subjected to simulated biological fluid assays to determine whether chemical components are likely to enter the human body;
    3. Characterize the ways in which people (athletes and children) interact with playing fields and playgrounds to understand exposure routes and exposure scenarios;
    4. Biomonitoring to be conducted in a small group of participants.

​​Click the link above to check for progress on this initiative.

  • Environmental Health Study of Synthetic Turf
    This initiative, carried out by the California Department of Resources Recovery and Recycling (CalRecycle) and funded by the California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA), aims to:
    1. Determine chemical constituents of crumb rubber;
    2. Determine what is released to the air under various conditions (with aging and weather conditions);
    3. Assess what humans are exposed to via ingestion and dermal contact based on specific activities and duration of those activities;
    4. Analyze exposure data according to exposure level, age group, and vulnerable groups (children);
    5. Develop a protocol for further biomonitoring, if required for future studies.

This work is in addition to two previous studies carried out in 2007 and 2010.

This list is not intended to be exhaustive. Omission of a resource does not preclude it from having value.

Last updated Nov 13, 2019